The contenders:
Cafe Rio
Bajio (at the Riverwoods)
Costa Vida (Pleasant Grove)
Mountain West Burrito (Provo)
Rancherito's, aka Beto's (Pleasant Grove)
Barbacoa (Alpine)
We gave each burrito an overall rating, and then also rated the proportions, the meat, the filling, and the tortilla. When we finished, we each ranked all of the burritos from 1 to 6.
Here's how things turned out:
Bajio and Cafe Rio ended up tying for first, with Costa Vida very close behind. Comments about these included:
"What I think of when I think of a pork burrito"
"You can tell they make their own tortillas"
"Just overall a really good flavor"
All of these three got a 1st place from at least someone. They were honestly all pretty similar to me in terms of whether or not I would eat them :)
Our fourth place was Mountain West Burrito. This one was a bit of an outlier because it really isn't sweet pork. That automatically made it Joel's favorite. He learned that he doesn't like sweet pork. I do think they had the best rice and beans, but I like other things from there a bit better.
Beto's and Barbacoa were definitely in last place. Beto's was just pork and guacamole...it really needed more toppings. The one from Barbacoa was not good. My pork was really fatty. I took three bites just in case I had a bad one the first time, but they were all so greasy. We got medium salsa, but it was mostly bland and tasted like canned corn.
We ended the party with tres leches rice pudding, games, and lots of fun "aunt and uncle" time. I don't think anyone changed their mind about their personal favorite restaurant, but it was really interesting to see how different all of them were!










































